Mark Collins – Cyber Espionage vs US Defence Industry: Chinese Resident of Canada Pleads Guilty

Further to this post,

Dragon Arrests Canadian: Retaliation for Our Help vs Chinese Spooking Against US?

it rather looks like the defendant cut a couple of deals, perhaps including being able eventually to return to Canada (why would we want him?):

B.C. multimillionaire pleads guilty to hacking into U.S. military for China

A multimillionaire Chinese citizen residing in Vancouver has admitted that greed led him to team up with hackers in his homeland in a conspiracy to steal blueprints for Pentagon military jet components.

Su Bin, a 50-year-old aviation entrepreneur, pleaded guilty in a California court this month to U.S. spying charges, prosecutors revealed on Wednesday [March 23].

Charges were first announced in 2014, but Mr. Su had been living in his adopted home of Canada fighting extradition. Then, a month, ago, he suddenly dropped his appeal, consented to cross the border, hired five lawyers and negotiated a maximum five-year prison sentence with U.S. prosecutors.

Independently, Canadian immigration authorities dropped a bid they had launched to declare Mr. Su a Chinese spy and strip him of his Canadian residency status. Government officials could not immediately say whether he can return to Canada to reside at the conclusion of his U.S. prison term, which has not yet been set…

According to a plea deal released on Wednesday, Mr. Su admitted he was part of a criminal hacking conspiracy that dates back to 2008 and continued to 2014.

During this time, Mr. Su used his aviation expertise to act as a data scout for two hackers based in China. He admits to helping them identify people, databases and documents they could hit within U.S. defence contracting companies. For example, the hackers would break into a secure database and then e-mail Mr. Su a long list of files in a directory. He would identify which English-language blueprint manuals were most worth taking.

China has hacking teams that are dedicated to military and aviation targets. The conspirators are said to have wanted schematics related to transport and fighter jets known to the Pentagon as C-17s, F-22s and F-35s. Corporate engineers were preparing to testify against Mr. Su, and say that technical documents discovered in his e-mail exchanges were part of projects that had cost U.S. taxpayers billions of dollars…

He still faces a significant fine for his crimes. Under the terms of his deal, he is responsible for “twice the gross gain or gross loss” of any financial damage that he did.

Prior to crossing into the United States to plead guilty, Mr. Su was also fighting a legal battle against Canada’s immigration enforcement arm, which had been trying to revoke his residency status.

“The Canada Border Services Agency has made an allegation of inadmissibility for security grounds against Mr. Su in late April, 2015,” said Melissa Anderson, a spokeswoman for the Immigration and Refugee Board. She explained that the CBSA alleged Mr. Su should be stripped of his status for “engaging in an act of espionage … that is contrary to Canada’s interests.”

But that bid was withdrawn three weeks ago, around the time Mr. Su crossed the border to negotiate a plea with U.S. authorities…

Court filings suggest Mr. Su negotiated his plea agreement with the help of five lawyers based in New York and Los Angeles. “I really can’t say anything more than what’s in the court filings,” said New York lawyer Robert Anello, when reached by phone. But when asked whether the five-year ceiling amounted to a significant reduction of potential prison time, he said that “it was.”

Despite Mr. Su’s admitted crimes, the heavy lifting in the conspiracy was done by two China-based hackers who have never been charged and whose names have never been revealed by prosecutors.

Earlier this year, The Globe and Mail revealed that court filings in Canada describe the tandem as “Chinese military officers” who sent Mr. Su pictures of themselves in military dress, with identifiable names and ranks.

Yet no publicly available U.S. charging document makes this same allegation. The plea agreement released on Wednesday refers to them only as “citizens of China and located in China”…

Maybe charges against the officers yet to come based on cooperation from Mr Su? Not that any trial will ever happen.

Lots more at


Mark Collins, a prolific Ottawa blogger, is a Fellow at the Canadian Global Affairs Institute; he tweets @Mark3Ds


7 thoughts on “Mark Collins – Cyber Espionage vs US Defence Industry: Chinese Resident of Canada Pleads Guilty”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s